
I had no idea who Chris Brown and Rianna (sp?) were until all of the news regarding their altercation hit the news. Ever since then I have been asked to comment about domestic violence. Did it on NPR and just this morning on a radio show in Chicago.
I haven't bought a CD that didn't day Best of. . . or Anthology. . . in years. So I am not up to date on today's music. (In fact still haven't heard any of their stuff)
Anyway, whether or not I know them I have been asked to comment on the general issue. Just this morning, I had a interesting conversation on the radio with a call in listener. There seems to be a great deal of "The Angry Black Woman" desreves what she gets going on. This leads me to two issues I see 1) a basic misunderstanding of domestic violence and 2) where are we as a culture and a society that there is so much anger and aggression by BOTH Sexes.
First before we continue I want to tell you a little about my background. When I was a municipal judge I saw hundreds of domestic violence cases every year. I headed a local version of a countywide attempt to have a systemwide response to domestic viloence. We wanted to do more than "adjudicate and go." We wanted to make a meaningful difference. So I know a bit about this on the systemic side.
Now - HEAR THIS at no point does anyone (male or female) deserve, earn or otherwise cause or make abuse inevitable. Angry words, insults or a verbal attack on hot button issues are not justification for getting hit. PERIOD.
One caller suggested that "ghetto fabulous" all day angry black women make brothers go there. He then said that a woman who behaves appropriately and in a feminine manner will not get hit. THIS IS NOT TRUE. Abusers and the abused come in all shapes and sizes. I adjudicated in a middle class neighborhood where women were getting hit because he didn't like dinner. There is a whole strata of abused women who are isolated frightened and demorailzed to such an extent that they can't get out, believe they deserve what they get etc. We also know from experience that one of the most dangerous times for a woman is when she tries to leave this kind of abuser - mortality shoots up.
Now I DO know that there is a cultural thing that's going on out there where sisters are angry aggressive confrontational etc. I dealt with them on the bench and they were the most difficult people for me to communicate with. This, I believe is a function of a lot of things. 1) what they saw in the home 2) young unmmaried mothers out there on their own raising children with little education - less money - minimal emotional support and no man. Talk about pressure. That kind of lack of control and constant stuggle makes people frightened and angry. Once those reactions become common place they become a cultural norm even when those conditions don't exist. People model what they see.
These are two separate problems that happen to run into one another. Both of these problems need to be addressed before anyone starts yelling or hitting.
1)We cannot continue to have babies having babies because while they are able to physical get them from 0 - 18 often they don't have the wisdom or support to create a stable environment and well adjusted kids. (Not always - I'm not dissing single moms - there have a tough job and some do miraculous things - what I'm saying that should not be the norm. We shouldn't have to do that. It's hard, there is too much room for error - and it just isn't right.)
2) Likewise DV is just unacceptable. Period. End of story - male or female. NOBODY deserves to have their own home be the scariest place for them to be. For centuries woman have traditionally not been considered the equal of men. In some cases women were considered chattel and for many years knocking around a woman a bit here and there was okay. We can't pretend that wasn't the case or that that problem no longer exists. It does.
We must address these issues separately but simoultaneously.
I became a mother for the first time at 32. It tested my patience even then. I know I would have raised a bunch of lunatics had I had one at 20. Especially if I were alone with no money? Please.
I am not passing judgment. I am telling you what I see and how its affecting us. Both problems are tough to solve but in the mean time in between time we must learn to control what we do by understanding that we do not have to act on how we feel.
We can communicate without cursing,
persuade without punching,
talk without taunting,
discuss without demeaning.
It is all about how we do with what we feel and our willingness to practice using emotional control BEFORE we get into a funky situation.
This is a huge topic I cannot do justice to here. In fact it's three huge topics: Domestic violence, Our Rage Prone Culture, And the disintigration of stable family structures. This blog is just a start. Something to muse over and get the discussion going.
Peace and I do mean Peace.